The Reader's Choice Award is presented to a Saskatchewan author for a title in any of the other Saskatchewan Book Awards competitions, as voted on by Saskatchewan readers in public libraries across the province.

indicates a review is available for that book

2009

• Marlene Millar, Dene Honϋ: Stories from the People

Also shortlisted:

• Tania Bird, Carla O’Reilly, Elita Paterson, Peggy Collins – The Smiling Mask
• Wilfred Burton, Anne Patton, Sherry Farrell Racette, Norman Fleury – Dancing in My Bones
• Amanda Deitz – Longer Than Life, Volume lll
• Wes Funk – Dead Rock Stars
• Wayne Kallio – Mind Gone Astray
• Olga Stefaniuk – A Rose Grows
• Nora Stewart – Cultivating Our Roots

2008

• Janita Van de Velde – Postcards Never Written

Also shortlisted:

• Diane Marie Armstrong – You're Going Where?!
• Kelly Buchanan, Robin Buchanan – The Snozels
• Hermie Carino – Journey to Aging Road
• Eusebio L Koh – Like the Mimosa
• Isa Milman – Prairie Kaddish
• Maureen Ulrich – Power Plays

2007

• Amanda Deitz – Longer than Life, Volume 2

Also shortlisted:

• Anthony Bidulka – Stain of the Berry
• Deana Driver – Never Give Up
• Michael P.J. Kennedy – Dogs on Ice
• Les Langager – Wild Justice
• Brian Trainor – Stop Fraud

2006

• Gail Bowen – The Endless Knot

2005

• Encyclopedia of Saskatchewan

2004

• Byrna Barclay – Girl at the Window

2003

• Lois Simmie – What I'm Trying to Say is Goodbye

2002

• Guy Vanderhaeghe – The Last Crossing

2001

• Deanna Christensen – Ahtahkakoop